Chaosium released the 40th Anniversary edition of the Starter Box set and I decided to check out the PDF, just to see what was new and/or changed. Unfortunately, I don't think they brought their A-Game with this one. I couldn't even get into the first booklet because the artwork just appeared, at least to me, to be horrifically bad. And bad not in a good Mythos way, either, just plain bad. See the example below.
Ugh. They all have this ridiculous look of terror, unusually large mouths agape, the female in the middle is holding up her skirt with one hand, the other almost looks like she's grabbing her cheeks in an attempt to not sh*t herself. I actually laughed when I saw this, which in no way inspired the dread of the Mythos, what-so-ever.
All of them just look so poorly drawn.
And then in one of the adventures from the Scenario PDF, there's this image:
This looks like something from the Sunday comics of the newspaper, or some random B-Grade comic book. I feel like CoC should have much more evocative and fear inspiring artwork, not whatever this is. Nothing about this makes me feel "cosmic horror".
Finally, though, this is probably the ONLY piece of artwork among the three PDFs that was remotely worth looking at. All of the artwork in the set should have been in this style or something similar. Yes, it could just be "any generic horror art" but at least it has a feel to it that doesn't draw a laugh or "wtf?". This was in the solo module,
Alone Against the Flames.
I feel sorry for anyone getting into CoC and picking up this box set, when so much of it is just awful to look at. Not sure why Chaosium went this route, but I'm definitely not a fan and would never consider picking up the printed product after seeing this.